Linus Torvald is convinced version control should be based on trust networks

Thanks to Jesse, I started exploring Git, a version control system alternative to CVS and SVN. Git is based on a very different metaphor. While in CVS/SVN there is one repository which is maintained in a single location, in Git there are as many repositories as users and all of them are maintained in a decentralized fashion, on all the machines of all the users. From centralization to decentralization, it is an interesting twist and change in perspective.
And so what about the risk of balkanization of code? And the fact that there are 10.000 (different) versions of the Linux kernel? Well, according to Linus, the answer is trust. Linus explains the metaphores behind git and the trust issues in an extremely interesting Google Talk.

From the talk of Linux (via Victor):

The way merging is done is the way real security is done, by a network of trust. if you have ever done any security work and it didn’t involve the concept of network of trust it was not a security work; it was a masturbation.
…we don’t know hundred people. We have five, seven, ten close personal friends…

This way of managing a software ecology is wonderfully adhocratic. There are now thousands different versions of the Linux kernel. Currently most of the people rely on Linus’ version but it is possible, in a perfect adhocratic way, that different people will rely on versions of different people. Go decentralized, go trust-based. Cool.

Subscribe to RSS Feed If you enjoyed reading this, subscribe to my RSS Feed
(you can always unsubscribe later)

3 Responses to this post.

  1. Bru's Gravatar

    Posted by Bru on 18.09.07 at 3:48 pm

    Mozilla Firefox 2.0.0.6 Mac OS

    Indeed. This reminds me of a (quite) old project of mine to manage personal knowledge. hmmm… if only I could find that stub code…

  2. paolo's Gravatar

    Posted by paolo on 18.09.07 at 3:48 pm

    Epiphany 2.18 Ubuntu Linux

    Maybe it is better to get GIT code, If you manage to get Linus’ trust, it is done, he will import changes from you! ;-)

  3. matt cutts's Gravatar

    Posted by matt cutts on 18.09.07 at 3:48 pm

    Safari 534.59.8 Mac OS X 10.6.8

    Good day! Would you mind if I share your blog with my zynga group?

    There’s a lot of people that I think would really
    enjoy your content. Please let me know. Thank you

    Also visit my bloog post :: matt cutts

Respond to this post

mcdonald army health centerbuy metronidazole online no prescription